Music... Eurovision
May. 12th, 2024 05:51 pmSo, now I went and listened to at least some of the Eurovision entries.
- The Swiss winning song is... okayish, I guess? Singer's good but not outstanding on the technical level. Their performance was enthusiastic and good enough, but the song itself is utterly forgettable as far as I'm concerned. I have no idea why it got so many high votes from the juries all over Europe; it seemed to have been significantly less popular with the audiences that voted, who also seemed to think it was musically nice enough but not outstanding.
- Lots of drama around Israel's presence; I don't want to comment on that mess beyond the purely musical here. Anyway, my feelings about that entry are the exact opposite: with a better singer (and, for that matter, a less predictable arrangement), that would have had the potential of being a really good song. Unfortunately, that lady can't sing. It's one of those cases... I'm sure she had voice lessons and all, but every time she uses an effect, it's like "I'm using this effect now, did you hear how nicely I executed that trick?" - nothing natural about it. Too bad.
- Best singer, imho, was the guy from France. He sounds truly great, and I think it was an excellent decision to let him sing large parts of the song without any distracting instrumentals; he definitely has the kind of voice and natural presence that let him carry the whole thing on his own. Unfortunately, the song was crap - supposed to be romantic, I guess, but crossed the border into kitsch land in unforgivable ways. A shame...
- I also loved both Ukrainian singers. Not so much the song itself, which was a pretty clumsy (and, in the end, also pretty forgettable) attempt at connecting folk music to more modern musical styles - but in terms of vocal technique, that was a flawless and very impressive performance. They ended up in third place, which I suppose is okay.
- I'm kind of torn about the Croatian entry that placed second (and not just because it's not my preferred type of music), but it was wildly popular with the fan audiences, so... Um... I mean, I can recognize it's a really excellent composition that actually successfully blends different genres. In terms of complexity and general creativity, it's a clear winner. Also, the choreography on stage was brilliant. (I hear the dance trended on TikTok, and while I don't use "social media", I can easily see why.) I just failed to connect with the song. It still should have won if you ask me, because it's really f*cking good.
- Germany, after some spectacular Eurovision failures in recent years, decided to play it safe and send the least offensive entry they could find. Clearly, the objective was, "what's going to make the lowest number of people yell at their family members to turn down that noise". Unfortunately, the result was predictably unoffensive-but-bland, mostly saved by the singer's decent performance, and the 12th place well deserved.
- The Swiss winning song is... okayish, I guess? Singer's good but not outstanding on the technical level. Their performance was enthusiastic and good enough, but the song itself is utterly forgettable as far as I'm concerned. I have no idea why it got so many high votes from the juries all over Europe; it seemed to have been significantly less popular with the audiences that voted, who also seemed to think it was musically nice enough but not outstanding.
- Lots of drama around Israel's presence; I don't want to comment on that mess beyond the purely musical here. Anyway, my feelings about that entry are the exact opposite: with a better singer (and, for that matter, a less predictable arrangement), that would have had the potential of being a really good song. Unfortunately, that lady can't sing. It's one of those cases... I'm sure she had voice lessons and all, but every time she uses an effect, it's like "I'm using this effect now, did you hear how nicely I executed that trick?" - nothing natural about it. Too bad.
- Best singer, imho, was the guy from France. He sounds truly great, and I think it was an excellent decision to let him sing large parts of the song without any distracting instrumentals; he definitely has the kind of voice and natural presence that let him carry the whole thing on his own. Unfortunately, the song was crap - supposed to be romantic, I guess, but crossed the border into kitsch land in unforgivable ways. A shame...
- I also loved both Ukrainian singers. Not so much the song itself, which was a pretty clumsy (and, in the end, also pretty forgettable) attempt at connecting folk music to more modern musical styles - but in terms of vocal technique, that was a flawless and very impressive performance. They ended up in third place, which I suppose is okay.
- I'm kind of torn about the Croatian entry that placed second (and not just because it's not my preferred type of music), but it was wildly popular with the fan audiences, so... Um... I mean, I can recognize it's a really excellent composition that actually successfully blends different genres. In terms of complexity and general creativity, it's a clear winner. Also, the choreography on stage was brilliant. (I hear the dance trended on TikTok, and while I don't use "social media", I can easily see why.) I just failed to connect with the song. It still should have won if you ask me, because it's really f*cking good.
- Germany, after some spectacular Eurovision failures in recent years, decided to play it safe and send the least offensive entry they could find. Clearly, the objective was, "what's going to make the lowest number of people yell at their family members to turn down that noise". Unfortunately, the result was predictably unoffensive-but-bland, mostly saved by the singer's decent performance, and the 12th place well deserved.